What Led Me to Clash With the Bulwark

November 19, 2026

Hey,

Back in 2016 I found myself at a dinner with Rich Lowry, then the editor of National Review and therefore my boss. Like many of my colleagues at National Review at the time, we were taking heat for not bowing to the Trump cause. A guest at the table asked, in a very courteous way, whether National Review would “come home” or “get on the Trump train,” or something to that effect. In answering, Rich explained that National Review contains a broad spectrum of voices. Then he said something like, “Look, at the end of the day, what people need to understand is we’re not the RNC.”

What he meant was that whatever conclusion National Review as an institution ultimately reached, it would do so for its own reasons as an independent publication, not as a mouthpiece for a political party, and even then some writers would still be free to dissent. This became something of a decal for me whenever I found myself in the same kinds of discussions. Yet it wasn’t a novel stance for me. I had written for years that I wasn’t really a “party guy” and didn’t want to be. For instance, I wrote a quarter century(!) ago:

“Well, this is as good a time as any to explain something. I am not particularly proud to be a Republican. Indeed, if you asked me, I would be more likely to say I vote Republican or I tend to root for the Republicans. I do this because I am a conservative and, like it or not, the Republican party is the party for conservatives. I know this statement bothers the six guys with a mimeograph machine over at the Howard Phillips office, but so be it. Obviously, there’s nothing wrong with being proud of being a Republican (or a Democrat). But it just ain’t my bag. Organized political enthusiasm — while necessary and noble — tends to annoy me when applied to large numbers of people, in much the same way I would rather stop an industrial fan with my tongue than ride a bus with the gang from Up With People.”

I’m not saying I was perfectly immune to partisan fervor or team loyalty. But that instinct remained my default. So when Donald Trump became the GOP nominee, appeals to party loyalty had very little traction with me. In those days it was easier to find people who agreed that Trump was terrible but Hillary Clinton was worse, and, therefore, I should vote for the lesser evil. I understood, and even had some sympathy for, that argument. I can say without fear of contradiction that I was not a fan of Hillary Clinton.

But even if I accepted the argument that I should vote for Trump (and I didn’t—I wrote in Paul Ryan’s name), that did not justify behaving like a public spokesman for the Republican National Committee. I cannot begin to count how many people disagreed with this. Longtime readers were furious with me. Talk radio hosts mocked me. Fox News personalities rolled their eyes at what they saw as my fastidious arrogance, disloyalty, and self-indulgence. Serious and unserious people alike insisted that once Trump secured the nomination, it was my obligation to do everything in my power to help him win or to ensure Hillary Clinton lost, as if I were a Republican politician. Now, I don’t actually believe Republican politicians are morally required to back the nominee, but there is at least a defensible argument for that. Still, I am neither a Republican politician nor a professional Republican.

To the extent I identified as a Republican, my thinking then was Hamiltonian: “If we must have an enemy at the head of government, let it be one whom we can oppose, and for whom we are not responsible, who will not involve our party in the disgrace of his foolish and bad measures.”

So why the stroll down memory lane?

Well, you may have heard that I got into an online spat with the folks at The Bulwark. For many readers of both outlets, it felt like a painful family quarrel. For many progressives it seemed almost comical, a People’s Front of Judea versus the Judean People’s Front sort of thing. That’s one of the perils of the tyranny of small differences: they aren’t small to the people inside the conflict.

It started with a video of Bulwark publisher Sarah Longwell at a Democratic Party conference in Colorado. She told the assembled Democrats, “You may know us, we’re the Never Trumpers. At least we were 10 years ago. Now we’re just kind of libs just like the rest of you.”

In response to the uproar, Longwell attempted to claim that she meant “classically liberal.” I found this to be, on its face, ridiculous. No one in that room heard that and thought, “Ah, she must mean like Lord Acton or Ludwig von Mises.” And Longwell clearly didn’t think the roomful of Democratic partisans was a gathering of the Mont Pelerin Society. It was spin, not a rational argument.

For many people, Longwell’s statement and her subsequent damage control confirmed a widely held belief that The Bulwark, founded in 2018 with the slogan that it was devoted to “conserving conservatism,” had become more of a Democratic-aligned outlet than a bulwark of conservatism.

In some cases, this isn’t really up for debate. Bill Kristol, the founder of The Bulwark, has been candid about it.

Kristol was once a fairly ardent pro-lifer, believing the GOP should strive for “an America in which every unborn child is protected in law and welcomed in life.” By 2024 he was weighing in on the side of Kamala Harris to use reproductive rights as a winning wedge issue. “Let the mansplaining political commentators wring their hands. Reproductive freedom is a crucial issue, and a winning one, and the Harris campaign would be foolish not to make it a closing one in these last couple of days.”

I understand the argument that opposing Trump might require backing Democrats in the House and Senate to form a counterweight to Trump’s consolidated power. As Longwell stated in her endorsement of Abdul El-Sayed, the anti-Israel, pro-abortion advocate for various left-wing transgender priorities, “I will endorse candidates with whom I have big differences for the bigger picture of putting an enormous check on Donald Trump.” Though I would never claim to mimic what Tim Miller did: “I could not be happier to endorse Abdul El-Sayed over the human trash that is Mike Rogers,” he said.

But if The Bulwark claims to be about conserving conservatism, I fail to see why Kristol supported Zohran Mamdani, a self-described democratic socialist and outspoken anti-Zionist, in the primary against Andrew Cuomo (who is not those things). He has supported Democratic governors as well. What this has to do with opposing Trump remains a mystery to me. I’m puzzled why a small-government, free-market guy would after the midterms that rebuked Trump call for a “New New Deal.”

I could run through quotes from other Bulwark contributors that clash with the claim that they have not altered their conservative or Republican principles. There are indeed good people at The Bulwark, including Kristol and Longwell. There’s no law that forbids changing your mind about politics or making strategic decisions about what you say about it.

So what’s the fuss about? My objection is simply honesty. Bill Kristol has always been part thinker, part operative. Longwell has always been an operative. Tim Miller is a former GOP communications guy. Indeed, Longwell and Kristol launched a Democrat-aligned PAC, and she maintains a side enterprise offering services to Democratic or anti-Trump candidates. Their editorial approach mirrors their view of politics, in my estimation, and I’m not alone in this assessment. In fact, one Bulwark contributor has made the plausible charge that the outlet spiked a piece it had commissioned because it would be bad for Democrats. If that’s true, it reflects poorly on its journalistic mission. But you know what? It’s fine if you view your mission as a united-front operation aligned with Democrats. My only complaint is that you should be upfront about it.

Putting partisan politics aside: as an intellectual, even a moral matter, if you change your view about the role of government, let alone about abortion, you should explain why and make the case on the merits—and by merits I do not mean “because it would be good for Democrats.” In fact, sometimes the causality runs the other way. If you chase policy positions that would help Democrats (or Republicans) long enough, you convince yourself those policy positions are simply right. That’s the story of many Republicans who shifted their stance to back Trump and his transformation of the party. Cynical partisanship is hard to sustain—eventually you come to believe what you’re saying. That’s why Longwell’s honesty about herself when she says, “we’re just kind of libs,” resonates.

Which brings us to how I found myself in the middle of this storm. I responded to Longwell’s “we’re just kind of libs just like the rest of you” with the remark that “Always Trump and Never Trump became two sides of the same coin.”

That sparked a back-and-forth with Andrew Egger, a former Dispatch writer who now lands at The Bulwark. I regret the tone and tenor of my exchanges with my friend, but I was annoyed by his insinuation that I didn’t truly believe what I said. For the last decade, people have accused me of lying or acting in bad faith on political issues. For some, sincere disagreement cannot be sincere unless it is driven by personal interest or some partisan agenda. In other words, it sounded to me as if Egger was projecting onto me a kind of political calculus that I suspect many of his colleagues actually practice. I don’t think that was his intention, but that’s how I perceived it.

But you know what? I meant what I said. No, I don’t think the anti-Trump and pro-Trump camps are morally equivalent—a view that Tim Miller and countless others were quick to attribute to me.

What I did mean was that these factions share what Whittaker Chambers described as the “Popular Front mind.” The idea that victory over the feared opponent justifies any means, and that every other concern must bow to the aim of defeating the opposing side. As George Orwell observed, that mentality can lead to the belief that “There is no crime, absolutely none, that cannot be condoned when ‘our’ side commits it.” In fairness to The Bulwark, I don’t think that fully captures its approach or mindset. But the unease over Graham Platner, support for Abdul El-Sayed, etc., points more in that direction than some of us realize.

Longwell is candid that this is her perspective. “Guys, I put all my policy preferences aside,” she recently said on a podcast. “I subvert my policy preferences in favor of how do we save America from what’s happening right now? And I think that should be the baseline of everybody who wants to be in the tent.” I suspect she meant “subordinate” rather than “subvert,” though subvert does feel like a Freudian slip.

Kristol is honest about it as well. “As long as you’re against authoritarianism and for the rule of law, and basically for a market system with a welfare state, basically for American global leadership, and basically for welcoming immigrants and for a tolerant nation, then I’m sort of okay with it. And so I found myself a little bit of a big-tent Democrat,” Kristol admitted.

How committed Zohran Mamdani, Abdul El-Sayed, and others are to “American global leadership” and the “market system” is something I’d like Kristol to elaborate on in due course.

I have substantial sympathy and considerable alignment with The Bulwark’s concerns about the dangers Trump and the new right pose. Anyone who reads what I’ve written over the past decade should reasonably come to a similar conclusion. That is why Longwell’s resort to accusing me and others of engaging in what she labels “anti-anti-Trumpism” strikes me as unfair—and, frankly, damning.

She is convinced she’s right about Trump, and I share much of that conviction. But she also presumes she knows what I know and think, and then assumes that because I don’t make the same choices she has about opposing Trump, I must be an “anti-anti-Trumper.” This framing, like the Cold War’s “Popular Front mind,” reduces everything to a single political clash of the moment, driving people to both “subvert” and subjugate their longer-held beliefs for the sake of the cause, and turning disagreement into a manufactured ideological stance.

The notion that I sit down at the computer and ask myself, “What is the anti-anti-Trump stance on this? How do I construct it?” is, to put it mildly, incomprehensible to me; I don’t know how to describe it any other way.

When I write, I ask, “What do I think about this?” or “What would be compelling or entertaining to explore?” The idea that I would do otherwise is the sort of thing a partisan or political operative might imagine. But I am neither. I don’t think like one, and I don’t want to become one. And interpreting that as some kind of hidden plan to serve a partisan end is just as wrong—and as unfair—as the numerous people who’ve accused me of secretly adoring Hillary Clinton or Kamala Harris.

I’m not saying this out of self-pity; I’m proud of most of my choices and comfortable with the rest. But after a decade of being attacked for refusing to act as if I worked for a Trumpified RNC, losing friends, money, and opportunities along the way, I find it deeply offensive—and also rather stupid—to be accused of doing exactly that, only in a more sophisticated mode. I’ve spent decades insisting that my sole obligation as a writer is not to lie. “Don’t write or say things you don’t believe to be true” sums up my journalistic ethic, in my view. That means I’ll occasionally defend positions that, in one sense, help Trump or Republicans (or Democrats). But that is incidental. Yes, I’ll present arguments—it’s what I do for a living—about what Democrats or Republicans ought to do, but my motive isn’t partisan, because I’m not a partisan.

When I said that Always Trump and Never Trump are two sides of the same coin, I did not intend to imply that Trump’s corruption and assaults on democracy are as grave as everything the Democrats or The Bulwark are doing or backing. I meant—and I still mean—that Popular Front thinking is a one-dimensional approach to politics. Hyperpartisanship has a place in a democracy, but it isn’t my place (and it isn’t the purpose of The Dispatch). After a decade of resisting the urge to act as if I served the Republican National Committee, I’m not about to pretend I serve the Democratic National Committee either. Subordinating or subverting one’s beliefs to secure electoral gains is not my job.

And one final point. The Bulwark and its defenders have adopted a pose that theirs is the more serious and principled path because it engages the fight against Trump more directly. That is a prudential judgment, not a matter of principle. We have lived through an era marked by widespread distrust of elites and elite institutions. Part of that distrust is the belief that “the media” is pushing a partisan agenda. I commend The Bulwark for being forthright about its mission. Would that MS NOW or Fox News were equally candid about their editorial choices. Perhaps, though, the way to restore norms would be to observe them even when they are politically inconvenient for your side. Or maybe we should simply stop thinking so much in terms of sides at all.

Pilar Marrero

Political reporting is approached with a strong interest in power, institutions, and the decisions that shape public life. Coverage focuses on U.S. and international politics, with clear, readable analysis of the events that influence the global conversation. Particular attention is given to the links between local developments and worldwide political shifts.